The Witness of a Murderer

The Witness of a Murderer
Fr. Varghese Paul, SJ
The word ‘witness’ has been given several meanings in the Oxford Dictionary like 1)
eyewitness, 2) person giving sw
orn testimony, 3) person attes
ting another’s signature to a
document. Witness as a verb means 1) be eyewitness
of, 2) be witness to 2)
serve as evidence or
indication of, 4) give
or be evidence, etc.
Witness has great importance in the investiga
tion and trial or count cases. Court accepts
eyewitness’ account of a crime as
evidence or proof of a case. If
a witness testifie
s what he/she
has seen in a court of law, the testim
ony is accepted as ev
idence of the case.
Here I would like to speak about such a witnes
s who is a murderer. Now the murderer not only
testifies to the innocence’s of his victim but he
also witnesses to values as well as to his faith!
I have written about the murderer’s heinous
crime in my newspaper
column in March 1995.
Under the title “Is our
humanism dead and gone” I wrote the account of Sr. Rani Maria’s
daylight murder. “Some unknown assailants had bruta
lly killed Sr. Rani Maria with more than 40
knife wounds during a bus journey at Kelda Gh
ati about 40 kilometers away from Indore.”
Reaching at Indore after the incident on Februa
ry 25, 1995, I came to know
that Sr. Rani Maria
was doing social services and welfare works among
the tribal Bheel people in the villages at
Udayanagar region of Madhya Pradesh. Sr. Rani
Maria was a popular person
in the villages of
the region as a well-educated and very capable social worker.
Sr. Rani Maria ran for the tribal as well
as other poor people such programmes like home
industries, digging wells, saving schemes. She ha
s been helping people to take advantage of
government projects and programmes for getting wa
ter, seeds manure and bank loans, etc. The
dedicated selfless servic
es of Sr. Rani Maria antagonized th
ose people who used
to exploit the
tribals and other poor people through money lending
with exorbitant interest and other ways of
overloading the helpless people. The exploiters sa
w Sr. Rani Maria as th
eir enemy and decided
to do away with her. They got a farmer Sa
mandar Singh to execute their devilish plan of
murdering Sr. Rani Maria while she
took a bus to Indore on home-leave.
The investigating authorities arrested Samandar Si
ngh. He was tried and convi
cted for life for the
heinous crime.
According to Asia News reports, behind the pr
ison walls Samandar Singh began plotting how he
could take revenge against the man who pushed him
to kill Sr. Rani Maria. While he was behind
bars, his wife divorced him and his elder son died.
But what brought a big transformation in Samand
ar Singh was the visit of a nun. Sr. Selmi Paul,
the murdered nun’s own Sister, also a member
of Clarist congrega
tion. On a Rakshabandhan
day, Sr. Selmi tied Rakhi on Samandar
Singh’s hand calling him a brother.
Later an elderly woman who came from Kerala
to visit the mission land of her two daughters
also paid a visit to Samandar in the jail. She wa
s the mother of Sr. Rani Maria and Sr. Selmi and
expressed her forgiveness and love for Samandar Singh.
Experiencing genuine love of people like
Sr. Selmi and her mother, Samandar became a
transformed man giving up his plans to take reve
nge against the man who pushed him to kill the
Then, in jail Samandar Singh came to know that the
forgiveness expressed by his victim’s sister
and mother was more than mere words. Sr. Se
lmi, her Clarist religio
us congregation and the
Bishop Geroge Anathil of Indore were tryi
ng to get him released from the prison.
As the Asia News has reported,
“when his release was slow in
coming, a delegation went to the
Governor of Madhya Pradesh to plead for his release.”
The Governor was moved by the petition of the de
legation please for mercy and clemency for the
murderer of a Christian religious sister.
“Only you Christians can truly forgive. You are a
great example. Go, I sha
ll do all I can to get
him released,” said the G
overnor assuring the delegate
s his help in the matter.
Being released after eleven years in prison Sa
mandar Singh considers the family of Sr. Rani
Maria as his own family. Visiting often th
e tomb of Sr. Rani Maria Samandar once
acknowledged, “I regularly visit he
r tomb, for me, it is like a sanc
tuary of peace and strength”.
Now Samandar is a witness not only for Christian
forgiveness but also of
Christian missionaries.
Asia News has quoted him saying, “I want everyone
to know that Christians work to make India
great. The missionaries give us
hope through their service, wh
ich is to make us strong and
independent people”.
Samandar knows well that in India many people of
the right wing party
of Sangh Parivar hate
Christians and instigate people to persecute them.
Voicing his personal experi
ence of the past, Samandar Singh told Asia News:
“Before they drove me to kill, I heard so
many hate-filled lies abou
t the missionaries and
Christians. They used to tell me that Christia
ns converted people through
tricks and that their
work with the poor was only for show. Now,
however, I can say without doubt that the
missionaries do nothing but work and help the poor and the marginalized. They have no secret
designs other than to serve God”.
Personally speaking I have often heard such accusa
tions against Christians and missionaries and
read false propaganda of Sangh Parivar people blam
ing Christians and missi
onaries with all sorts
of lies that they are proselytizin
g poor people with allurements. I
hope that to all
such people the
witness of Samandar Singh is an eye opener and a convincing response. (contact the author:
(Last Changed : 16-07-2010)
(Next Change : 01-08-2010)
Fr. Varghese Paul © Copyright 2010